Iwata Asks is a series of interviews conducted by former Nintendo Global President Satoru Iwata with key creators behind the making of Nintendo games and hardware.



Iwata Asks Home

Nintendo 3DS



Volume 1 And That's How the Nintendo 3DS Was Made

How Will It Catch On?

Miyamoto

The other day, I was talking about Touch Generations. Oh…do you know what Touch Generations is?

Itoi

Like Brain Age: Train Your Brain in Minutes a Day!24 and English Training: Have Fun Improving Your Skills!25

Miyamoto

Right, right. 24. Brain Age: Train Your Brain in Minutes a Day!: A game released for the Nintendo DS system in May 2005.

25. English Training: Have Fun Improving Your Skills!: A game released in Japan and Europe for the Nintendo DS system in 2006.

Iwata

Nintendogs belongs to that category as well. As a new challenge, we grouped together several titles that children, their parents and grandparents—three generations—could play together regardless of their knowledge and experience of video games. And we labeled that group Touch Generations.

Itoi

Yes, I remember that.

Miyamoto

We started it up as a brand that people playing video games for the first time could buy without worrying, and it led to rather positive result for Nintendo DS. So with regard to how to handle Touch Generations for Nintendo 3DS, we had some discussions among ourselves.

Itoi

Uh-huh.

Miyamoto

But when you think about it, Nintendo DS came out as a game system unlike any before, and we gave Touch Generations its name to suggest that even people who don't usually play video games could play those games without fretting. When considering the basic element of playing games by touching the screen with the stylus, we thought there might not be much point to making another Touch Generations for Nintendo 3DS, which is just going to be an extension of Nintendo DS.

Itoi

Oh?

Miyamoto

When we thought about what kinds of activities a new player who doesn't know much about games could enjoy on a Nintendo 3DS, what came to mind was taking 3D photos, watching 3D videos, things like that.

Itoi

In other words, functions in the system itself.

Miyamoto

Right. Not separate software.

Iwata

You could say that the system itself fulfills the role of Touch Generations.

Miyamoto

Of course, demand will continue for those Touch Generations games that buoyed Nintendo DS, so we will continue to make them.

Itoi

I see.

Iwata

But we decided that, whereas before we had established a Touch Generations brand, created special corners in shops and used a special logo, the company has decided not to use this brand name for Nintendo 3DS.

Itoi

Oh, I see.

Miyamoto

We won't use Touch Generations in the future.

Iwata

When I proposed that at an inner-company meeting where we would decide our policy the other day and asked if it was okay, everyone immediately agreed. (laughs)

Itoi

Oh, really? Even the sales people?

Iwata

Even them. I hate to brag about our own company, but I have to say that I thought this was quite amazing. (laughs)

Itoi

Yeah…

Miyamoto

Someone responsible in our sales department said something like that the mindset of dragging along the past, constantly adding little variations to it, will never give birth to a new culture. (laughs)

Iwata

Right, right! (laughs)

Miyamoto

I thought that was incredible.

Itoi

It really is. (laughs)

Iwata

I try to not use the word "success" to describe our situation as it may stir egoistic emotions which may lead us to be drowned in it. I would say that Touch Generations was one example of success. But to do the same thing is merely playing defense.

Itoi

Yeah. (laughs)

Iwata

Deciding that we wouldn't use that name again would allow everyone to tackle their work anew.

Miyamoto

There's a feeling that this hardware itself is Touch Generations.

Iwata

Something else you can say is that it's no longer surprising to talk about older people playing video games. People with no video game experience now have a way to get started, so game systems now belong to everyone regardless of age, gender or experience.

Itoi

Uh-huh.

Iwata

I think the time for making such distinctions by using such a word has ended.

Itoi

That's right. Thinking within that framework no longer pertains.

Miyamoto

You can say that about game makers too. For example, when it came to Touch Generations, while it was a series different from previous games, the same development teams were making the software. But when it comes to, say, editing 3D videos26 for Nintendo 3DS that we are planning to distribute using SpotPass, that's all being produced by teams outside of development. 26. 3D videos that we are planning to distribute using SpotPass: In Japan, Nippon Television Network Corporation and Fuji Television Network are each working in partnership with Nintendo to provide daily distribution of free 3D contents created by the networks to Nintendo 3DS using the SpotPass functionality. 3D video distribution plans have not been officially announced outside Japan as of this interview.

Itoi

Oh, I see.

Miyamoto

So makers have to make changes, too. If you assume that those who have made the games so far are the only ones to make anything, the chances of making new software are ruined right at the start.

Itoi

Yeah, right.

Miyamoto

But I guess that's internal business. Not something to talk about here. (laughs)

Iwata

(laughs)

Miyamoto

To return to what we were discussing before, I think it would be interesting if companies other than Nintendo were more involved with Nintendo 3DS. Like, I think it would be fun if movie directors made 3D movies for it seriously.

Iwata

Along with that is the question of how players will make use of it.

Miyamoto

Right.

Itoi

That's really something to look forward to.

Iwata

Nintendo actually has a lot of projects underway that call on players' creativity. Like Flipnote Studio27 and Make It Yourself: Nintendo DS Guide.28We disseminate these materials in the hope that players' creations will draw in others and lead to greater enjoyment for all. It would be great if that led to big changes and revealed a new pillar of entertainment. Miyamoto-san, you think there's something there, don't you?

Miyamoto

Yes. I intend to dig it up! (laughs) 27. Flipnote Studio Free DSiWare released in Japan in December 2008 (called Flipnote Studio in the U.S.). It allows users to create hand-drawn images with the stylus. Users can play multiple pages successively, resulting in flipbook animation.

28. Make It Yourself: Nintendo DS Guide: Free DSiWare released in Japan in November 2010. It allows users to create guide services by assembling photographs and sound clips taken with Nintendo DSi or Nintendo DSi XL systems.This title was not released outside of Japan as of this interview.

Itoi

Ideally, you nail down the base enjoyment and don't allow anyone to get a word in, so that no matter what the players say, you don't budge, but then, after release, you say, "Now do whatever you want with it." I suppose that balance is good.

Miyamoto

That's right. Our basic attitude toward the players is, "Please, be as creative and add as much as you can."

Itoi

What's similar, but no good, is muddling what you need to set right at the start.

Iwata

Well, oh, I see.

Itoi

When you make something in constant worry over what everyone thinks, you never solidify that basic element for players to enjoy. In that way, I'm really looking forward to the Nintendo 3DS system.

Iwata

Yeah. I'm not really sure what will happen—how the world will take it, how it will catch on—when this system, which provides such peculiar enjoyment, suddenly falls into players' hands.

Itoi

Yeah, I suppose not.

Iwata

But that uncertainty is exciting!