Iwata Asks is a series of interviews conducted by former Nintendo Global President Satoru Iwata with key creators behind the making of Nintendo games and hardware.





Special Edition: Creative Small Talk

Productive Meetings

Miyamoto

A lot of meetings don't go well when they are organized too well.

Itoi

Oh, yeah.

Miyamoto

What is that about? Some meetings are awful.

Itoi

It may sound extreme, but meetings are no good when someone has to say, "All right, then…" in order to officially start it.

Everyone

(laughs)

Miyamoto

I think a pattern of good meetings is that someone attending the meeting can say, "I'm not so sure" to the proposal made there.

Itoi

Ahh.

Miyamoto

It's no good if someone doesn't at least once introduce some creative destruction, like, "I'm not so sure…" Something that is broken down and reassembled has greater reality.

Iwata

That's right.

Itoi

What I often say is "That's fine, but…" Things start going well with, "That's fine, but…"

Miyamoto

Oh…

Iwata

Conversation that kicks off with, "That's fine…" and "But…"

Itoi

Right, right. I blurt out, "That's fine, but…" when I myself don't really know what it is I want to say! But I can't pass it through the way it is, or I can, because it's basically all right, but I'm like, "Isn't it a little boring like that?" So what I say after "That's fine, but…" is what reflects my values.

Miyamoto

That's right.

Itoi

Like, "Isn't that a little boring?" or "Aren't you avoiding what you should really be doing?" Or, "Don't you think the fans may not like that?"

Miyamoto

Right. It's important that the values of someone who says that—the values of a single person—rework the problem once. Then its get more real.

Itoi

Even when something hasn't come together yet, it gets much better if someone else's values break it down once, like, "No, not like that…"

Miyamoto

On the other hand, when it comes to everyone deciding together, it lacks sharpness or something like that.

Iwata

Yeah. When a meeting yields results, you didn't decide anything by consensus, but rather, somebody laid their opinion on the line.

Itoi

Yes, I really believe that.

Miyamoto

To go back a bit, during those sessions we have during lunch, I have these boisterous conversations with Iwata-san or Nakago-san while we eat, and when everyone returns to work, we divide into those who take the stairs up and those who go down.

Iwata

Nakago-san is on B1, while Miyamoto-san is on 5 and I'm on 7.

Miyamoto

Yeah, I climb up the stairs. And before we part, we stop and stand a bit around the handrails and briefly sum up, like, "So the gist of today's conversations was..." I feel like a lot of times that is important.

Itoi

Uh-huh…

Iwata

You draw a conclusion.

Miyamoto

In the end, that about sums it up. I say, "I'll give it a shot," and go up the stairs and think about it some more.

Iwata

For a little while afterward, you each work as individuals. Then you gather again for lunch. If you think about it, it's an unusual way of working.

Miyamoto

Yeah. (laughs) I wonder about that.

Itoi

But it shows good work relations.

Everyone

(laughs)